This series looks at the biggest opening weekends for the month since 1980. If it made the Top 200, it has a chance to appear here.

This Weekend in History highlights a well-received serious horror movie, a recent hit Western, a comedy ahead of its time, a sports drama with then unknown / now well known actors, a stinker that marked the end of an action hero’s reign, and 5 Cult Classics.

If you’re hungry for more make sure to check out the companion piece over at A TALE OF TWO DANS. 

The Top 200 of September doesn’t have many giant blockbuster hits. Like August, this month is a traditional dumping ground for Hollywood. The box office grosses aren’t nearly as high as your typical month. That said, this series combs through the best of the rest. There are a few nerdy titles worth watching / remembering.

* note: box office figures are domestic and are not adjusted for inflation *


OPENING WEEKEND: $30 million   //   BOX OFFICE TOTAL: $75 million

Here is the Number 1 movie for This Weekend in History, ranking #10 overall for the month. This surprise horror hit tackles the subject matter of demonic possession from supernatural and scientific points of view. It’s refreshing to have a thrilling movie like this played off as real and be just as terrifying. Whether you believe in demons or not, this terrifying character drama will keep you captivated. This compelling film also features stand-out direction and impressive performances from Jennifer Carpenter (DEXTER, QUARANTINE) and Tom Wilkinson.

3:10 TO YUMA – Sept. 7, 2007

OPENING: $14 million   //   TOTAL: $54 million

Russell Crowe and Christian Bale team up for this Western involving a train robbery. While slow at times, the action is beautifully crafted. The 2000s haven’t seen too many quality Westerns, although this year has a couple big ones on the horizon. Until then, watch one of the genre’s best recent entries.


OPENING: $9 million   //   TOTAL: $36 million

This cult smash was way ahead of its time. Masculine action heroes, Patrick Swayze and Wesley Snipes, lead the way in the this Drag Queen road trip comedy. The audience rewarded this bold film. The box office might not seem so impressive, but this was 20 years ago. $50 million was a big success then. The performances are a real highlight, but so are the laughs. While the movie has a message too, it’s most memorable for how fun it was.

WARRIOR – Sept. 9, 2011

OPENING: $5 million   //   TOTAL: $14 million

Tom Hardy and Joel Edgerton starred in this before they were on their way to becoming household names. This summer both of these rising stars had great success, with MAD MAX and THE GIFT, respectively. This sports drama follows brothers competing in the same MMA tournament. The sequences in the octagon are so intense, filmed with a sportscast sense of realism. This movie was a quality surprise. Watch out for a great supporting performance from Nick Nolte too.

FIRE DOWN BELOW – Sept. 5, 1997

OPENING: $6 million   //   TOTAL: $16 million

90s action hero Steven Seagal saw his run of hits come to an end with this stinker. Known for his fast martial arts skills, Seagal started to take his work too seriously. While being a b-movie star, he seems to have envisioned himself as an Oscar worthy dramatic type, inserting heavy-handed messages into his movies. This was just the beginning of that unfortunate trend.


STIR OF ECHOES – Sept. 10, 1999

OPENING: $6 million   //   TOTAL: $21 million

Kevin Bacon stars in this super creepy atmospheric horror. The scares were slow and deliberate, working its way under your skin. David Keopp (screenwriter of JURASSIC PARK) directs the proceedings in this underrated supernatural horror flick. Worth the watch for fans of the genre.

BULLETPROOF – Sept. 6, 1996

OPENING: $6 million   //   TOTAL: $22 million

One of my favourite Adam Sandler movies. I grew up with him on SNL, and laughed my way through his CDs numerous times. This R-rated action comedy co-starred Damon Wayans and helped make Sandler a household name. This was way before his family movie days.

For fans of sophmoric R-rated Sandler, but also fans of buddy action flicks. Hilarious, quotable, and well worth the watch.

CITY BY THE SEA – Sept. 6, 2002

OPENING: $9 million   //   TOTAL: $22 million

Robert DeNiro stars in this drama / thriller hybrid. It’s memorable for James Franco in an early role. He was quite intriguing in this character piece. While this indie gem divided the critics and audience, it’s worth watching, especially for fans of Franco’s more serious acting roles.

STIGMATA – Sept. 10, 1999

OPENING: $18 million   //   TOTAL: $50 million

Patricia Arquette stars in this religious horror movie. She begins to experience supernatural afflictions, like bearing the wounds of Christ. This film would probably do really well in today’s market. Check out those numbers. Gabriel Byrne also stars in this stylized and intense popcorn muncher. Worth the watch for today’s fans of demonic possession movies.

CELLULAR – Sept. 10, 2004

OPENING: $10 million   //   TOTAL: $32 million

Chris Evans starred in this action thriller a few years before he donned the shield as Marvel’s Captain America. His co-star was another rising action star, the one and only Jason Statham. This was actually a good straight-forward low-budget action flick. It was intense, and had good performances for the genre, including co-star Kim Basinger. The simple premise drives what is essentially a chase for the entire runtime.

What do you think?

2007 Honourable Mention: SHOOT ‘EM UP – Total: $13 million

Leave a comment below.

Missing your favourite? Maybe it’s on the 2D companion list?

2001 Stinker: THE MUSKETEER – Total: $27 million


7 thoughts on “THIS WEEKEND IN BOX OFFICE HISTORY – September: Part 1

  1. Hmm. Quite a few here that I never saw, including Bulletproof back when I did like Adam Sandler (I know people hate him now but he had some good movies, dammit!). I remember liking Stigmata – I should watch it again. And, ugh – I’ve just forced myself to watch Warrior for my IMDB Top 250 thing. I was bored out of my mind! Great post – I like how it’s a mix of lots of different types of movies. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

So... What'd you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s